Nick Robertson’s unfortunate knee injury sustained during pre-season in September 2024 casts a long shadow over the Toronto Maple Leafs’ roster heading into the 2024-25 NHL season. While initially feared to be season-ending, the prognosis indicates a potential return around the All-Star break, leaving a significant void on the left wing.
Robertson, coming off a promising albeit inconsistent 2023-24 campaign where he showcased his offensive skill and tenacity, was projected to be a key contributor in the Leafs’ top-nine forward group. His speed and shot were anticipated to add a dynamic element to the offense, potentially alongside John Tavares or Max Domi. With his absence, the Leafs are forced to re-evaluate their forward lines and consider internal and external solutions.
Internally, the injury creates an opportunity for players vying for roster spots. Matthew Knies, after a strong playoff showing in 2023, and if he continues his upward trajectory, would likely be bumped higher in the lineup and could be given an extended look alongside elite players. Another intriguing option is Pontus Holmberg. His versatility and defensive responsibility could earn him more ice time and a chance to showcase his offensive capabilities. Nick Abruzzese, who has demonstrated offensive flair in the AHL, might be given a chance to prove himself at the NHL level.
The injury also puts pressure on other wingers to elevate their game. Tyler Bertuzzi, acquired in the off-season, will need to consistently provide secondary scoring. Calle Jarnkrok, known for his adaptability, may be asked to play a larger role offensively. The Leafs are likely hoping Domi can step up and cement his place as a reliable top-six player.
Externally, the Leafs management might explore the trade market. However, given the uncertainty surrounding Robertson’s return timeline, they are unlikely to make a significant move early in the season. Instead, they might consider acquiring a short-term rental player to bolster their forward depth until Robertson is healthy. The team also has to be mindful of their salary cap situation, limiting their ability to acquire high-priced talent. Another strategy might be monitoring waiver wires for potential value signings, adding depth and competition without major cap implications.
Robertson’s injury undeniably complicates the Leafs’ roster construction and offensive strategy. The coaching staff and management will need to be creative in finding solutions to fill the void and maintain a competitive edge in the Eastern Conference. How they manage this challenge in the first half of the season will be crucial in determining their success and setting the stage for Robertson’s eventual return.